Queens' Favorite Since Day One

Every Slice Tastes Like Home

Hand-stretched dough, San Marzano tomatoes, and real mozzarella — baked fast in a blazing-hot oven. This is the pizza your neighborhood has been waiting for.

Call to Order See the Menu

Freshly baked pizza pulled from a wood-fired oven, cheese stretching, steam rising

Ready in 15 min Hot & fresh, every time

Made with love Fresh ingredients daily

Our Story

Pizza Made the Way It Should Be

Chef stretching pizza dough by hand in a bustling kitchen

Pizza baking in a hot brick oven with a wooden peel

Fresh mozzarella, basil, and San Marzano tomatoes on a wooden board

More than just a slice — it's a tradition.

Carlos Pizza started with one belief: great pizza doesn't need a fancy menu. It needs good dough, fresh toppings, and an oven that runs hot. That's still exactly what we do — every single day.

Located right here in Queens, we've been serving our neighbors real New York pizza made from scratch. No shortcuts. No frozen crusts. Just flour, water, salt, tomatoes, cheese, and a whole lot of care.

100% Fresh, never frozen

Daily Dough made from scratch

450° Oven temperature

Why Carlos Pizza

What Makes Us Different

It's not just about the pizza. It's about the experience — from the first call to the last bite.

Fresh Dough Daily

Every batch of dough is mixed, fermented, and stretched by hand each morning. No exceptions, no shortcuts.

Real Ingredients

San Marzano tomatoes, whole-milk mozzarella, fresh herbs — we source the best because your taste buds deserve it.

Hot Out of the Oven

Our ovens run at 450°F+, giving every pizza that perfect charred crust and bubbly, golden cheese — every single time.

A Neighborhood Spot

We know our regulars by name. This isn't a chain — it's your corner pizzeria, and we treat every guest like family.

What People Say

Loved by the Neighborhood

Don't take our word for it — hear from the folks who keep coming back.

"This is hands down the best pizza in Queens. The crust is perfect — crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. My family drives here specifically for the Margherita."

Michael R. Regular since 2019

"I order from Carlos Pizza at least twice a week. The quality is always consistent, the delivery is fast, and the BBQ Chicken is absolutely incredible. Can't recommend it enough!"

Sarah T. Queens local

"Finally, a real pizzeria in the area that cares about what they serve. You can taste the difference — fresh dough, quality toppings, and that perfect char. It's my go-to for family dinners."

David L. Metropolitan Ave resident

Every Slice Tastes Like Home

Margherita

Pepperoni

Garden Supreme

BBQ Chicken

Hawaiian

Classic NY Slice

Fresh Dough Daily

Real Ingredients

Hot Out of the Oven

A Neighborhood Spot

Ready for a Slice?

Come Say Hi